I have little to no knowledge of the graphic novel/comic book world (Aaack! Are they the same thing? Incomparable? I have no idea) but I have always been intrigued by it. Mostly because when I lived in St. Louis I worked with a guy who was majorly into comics; every week he would have some random graphic novel he would be reading instead of helping me deal with the insane kids at the Catholic school we were supposed to be working at. One day I asked what he was reading and he showed me the book. It was a graphic novel/comic book about the lives of the saints; each saint was drawn by a different artist. Now, you may or may not know that I have a mild obsession with saints (and nuns too) so this book made me think graphic novels were amazing and that I should maybe possibly get into them. Then about a month later he never came back to work and I forgot to start loving comic books.
But I digress.
We saw Watchmen on Saturday. Like I said, I know nothing of the genre or this story in particular; and while the movie definitely had its flaws, there was a lot of stuff I liked about it. Here is my un-educated review of the film.
Stuff I Did Not Like
1. Length of Film/Too Much Info
Three hours? This thing should have been two movies that were each two hours. There was not a second to breathe in this film-it was information packed at every turn. My years of writing for Lovewell have taught me that when a script is just one plot point bumping into another, the audience just can’t take everything in. I really would have appreciated a little time to breathe/reflect on what was happening; I missed some of the nuances of the movie thanks to this.
2. The Music
This kinda makes both lists. When it worked it was cool. When it was bad, it was just…bad. Too much of the music was just hitting you in the face with “HEY! We’re making a POINT over here!!!” The frightening live Cohen version of “Hallelujah?” It made me laugh (of course that could have also been the weird-ass sex scene it was supposed to be “accenting”). I seriously think there should be a moratorium on ever using this song in a movie ever, ever again. Stick a fork in it, it’s done.
3. Dr. Manhattan’s Mars Sculpture
What the hell was this? Why did it break? Why Mars? I don’t have the answers.
4. Character Development?
I really wish I could have connected emotionally with these characters. I just couldn’t. I loved Rorschach, but I still didn’t have a rounded idea of who he was. Again, just too much stuff crammed in too small a space.
5. Blue Penis
Why? Just…why? Why did he wear a codpiece in Vietnam and it had to be nudie-town when he chillaxed on his own? He wore clothing on the TV show; clearly he knows our conventions. Or at least why couldn’t he have Ken-like genitals? Seriously, why?
Stuff I Liked
1. Jackie Earle Haley as Rorschach
Wow. He was fantastic! I really like him as an actor and his personal life story makes it easy to root for him. He had the craziest eyes…I just thought he was great. I liked his character the best too; moral absolutism is interesting to watch.
2. Opening Sequence
I loved the tableaus during the credits. I know most people hated them, but I am a sucker for Dylan (I loved the music during the tableaus; it seemed bizarre and out of place not unlike the superheroes themselves in the Watchmen world) and I thought that the whole “evolution of the superhero” as shown was really cool. They were a tad long, but overall it made me feel intrigued and sympathetic for the characters I was about to meet.
3. The Gore
It was horrifying but kinda awesome too. Sawing someone’s wrists off? Slow-mo bullet through the leg? A gallon of blood pouring under a door? Ok, sure!
4. The Elk/Zebra/Tiger Hybrid
What the hell was this?! I wanted it to eat someone or do something exciting but instead it just got radiated (?) with Dr. Manhattan for no apparent reason. Did it die? I have no idea. Whatever, it was kind of cool.
5. The Visuals
The glass of the window breaking when the Comedian was thrown through was amazing to see. There were several great visual moments that stuck out to me. These were some of the only things that made it possible for me to sit on my increasingly numb ass for three hours.
6. Overall Ideas
I love stories about people trying to fit in after they have outlived their usefulness in their former roles. I think this was one of the main ideas of this movie and I am always intrigued by art that explores it. I also loved the phrase “Who Watches the Watchmen?” It’s kind of like asking “Who Takes Care of God?” I enjoy that idea as well. Also, I liked the non-cut-and-dried-ness of the heroes/villains, as I am a fan of having to think when I see movies (sometimes).
I totally get why people loved this movie, I totally see why they hated it. I really want to hear from one of my more graphic novel-y educated pals who knows more about Watchmen who can enlighten me with their opinion.